[Luinadar]

Eurytus:
"But to call it the best of all time? Ludicrous. Whilst it may be some peoples favourite movie, favourite is not necessarily best."
'Ludicrous' why? Because an auditor like you says so? Then what is 'best' to be defined as then? One persons Ben Hur is another persons cheese-fest, there is no real answer and you know it. Its very easy to condescend and criticise without offering your own choices up for analysis Eury.
Why are you so worked up at the few overexuberant Tolkienites who get a bit passionate about the voting, its a pity you don’t feel equally motivated about things that really matter though too.

"And yet why is it so necessary that LOTR wins? "

Never said it was.