The Barrow-Downs Discussion Forum - View Single Post - Tol-in-Gaurhoth XXII: Hic Monstrae Trucidant

Cailín · 05-30-2006, 03:14 PM

What I despise about Day 1s is that I always wish to trust everyone. It's very difficult to determine guilt toDay and there hasn't really been anyone enormously suspicious or controversial.

Caranlondien - there was something different about her, then it disappeared and now she's being defensive. I'm not quite sure what to make of her.

Mithalwen - well, her vote for Fea is understandable from a certain perspective, but I don't think it's entirely fair.

Formendacil - I know it is characteristic of him to act like this on Day 1, but I think he has been more silent and sullen than usual, even.

Nilpaurion Felagund - I mistrust him a little, which has little to do with reasoning (or chess or Pokemon).

LMP & Mormegil have not yet contributed as much as I would expect, but I'm willing to 'let that slide'. That means I'll shall be waiting to hear some extensive theories on why Sauce (or insert another random name) is guilty tomorrow.

Lommy has already managed to gather some suspicion. I don't really see anything horribly different about her.

Nogrod is usually quite transparent and seems as innocent as they come.

Spawn and Fin are reasonable, so is Celuien. We need some of those people around. If they are wolvish, that would be err.. troublesome.

Sauce has resumed his clueless villager act. And has also said some pretty worthwhile things. I won't like to see him die just yet.

TGWBS has not been extremely helpful (and he voted for me, effectively breaking my record of not being voted for for three games in a row - which is extremely nasty

) but that's usually how he acts on Day 1 especially when he has a limited amount of time. Fea somehow fits into the same category.

Boromir seems innocent and his retractable voting thing nothing more than a way to get some serious responses. Which is good, we need the discussion.

Durelin has been rather random and quirky, but that just seems to be her style.

Tom is new to the game. I would not see him go on Day 1.

I voted initially for Lhuna, because that's what the script told me to do, but we need a mind of our own, don't we? She's not on my suspect list (which is actually a rather 'big' word for my hunches).

I will vote within 15 minutes for one of the first four people on this list, I'm afraid. Unless someone jumps up and starts confessing.

05-30-2006, 03:14 PM	#100
Cailín Ghost Prince of Cardolan Join Date: Jun 2005 Location: Lurking in the shadows. Posts: 711	What I despise about Day 1s is that I always wish to trust everyone. It's very difficult to determine guilt toDay and there hasn't really been anyone enormously suspicious or controversial. Caranlondien - there was something different about her, then it disappeared and now she's being defensive. I'm not quite sure what to make of her. Mithalwen - well, her vote for Fea is understandable from a certain perspective, but I don't think it's entirely fair. Formendacil - I know it is characteristic of him to act like this on Day 1, but I think he has been more silent and sullen than usual, even. Nilpaurion Felagund - I mistrust him a little, which has little to do with reasoning (or chess or Pokemon). LMP & Mormegil have not yet contributed as much as I would expect, but I'm willing to 'let that slide'. That means I'll shall be waiting to hear some extensive theories on why Sauce (or insert another random name) is guilty tomorrow. Lommy has already managed to gather some suspicion. I don't really see anything horribly different about her. Nogrod is usually quite transparent and seems as innocent as they come. Spawn and Fin are reasonable, so is Celuien. We need some of those people around. If they are wolvish, that would be err.. troublesome. Sauce has resumed his clueless villager act. And has also said some pretty worthwhile things. I won't like to see him die just yet. TGWBS has not been extremely helpful (and he voted for me, effectively breaking my record of not being voted for for three games in a row - which is extremely nasty ) but that's usually how he acts on Day 1 especially when he has a limited amount of time. Fea somehow fits into the same category. Boromir seems innocent and his retractable voting thing nothing more than a way to get some serious responses. Which is good, we need the discussion. Durelin has been rather random and quirky, but that just seems to be her style. Tom is new to the game. I would not see him go on Day 1. I voted initially for Lhuna, because that's what the script told me to do, but we need a mind of our own, don't we? She's not on my suspect list (which is actually a rather 'big' word for my hunches). I will vote within 15 minutes for one of the first four people on this list, I'm afraid. Unless someone jumps up and starts confessing.