Currently I'm a bit stumped, after Valier I'm not sure who to think about. I kind of reverted to tunnel vision on her and tried to keep an open mind but what I want to do is give my general impressions on people; this is going to be more feeling based and analytical.
Diamond--Talkative but Roa brought up good points about her and I think that she would be a good wolf choice, as far as EW goes I doubt it, she would be a fine EW but I see wolfishness in her behavior not EWness.
Caranlondien--I feel that she is suspcious yet quietly so. She doesn't over react to things and keeps cool. I don't think she should be faulted for that but the things that concerns me the most is her level of 'participation'. She's seems very noncommital but posts a lot so as to appear to be active and involved.
Roa Aoife--I can see why there is some suspicion swirling around her and the question needs to be asked--Is Valier the type to attempt a bold bluff? I'm not convinced of that she would. Has had some good analysis of other villagers.
Dancing Spawn of Ungoliant--She's cunning to say the least. I don't believe her guilty though, but admittedly she seems less insightful than normal with the exclusion of yesterday.
Kath--Always guilty no matter what (Read: Past experience) so she should die. But seriously she's not contributing as much as normal and that always gets me worried but I will refrain from any judgement on this and ask an independent third party to analyze her.
Lommy--I can envision her as guilty, but then again would Lommy have defended Valier is Lommy is guilty? She's talkative but not over analytical. Currently she'd go in the 'uncertain but watching pile'.
Glirdan--Far too little talk and I always fear that this could be a diversionary tactic. Of course he wouldn't be a wolf because he's never around...but then wouldn't that be just perfect?
Sleepy Ranger--Smae as Glirdan
Kitanna--Has had me extremely worried until yesterday. That could mean that she's had more time or that she was a night 4 wolf convert and is now putting on a good show of being innocent.
Alcarillo--He keeps coming back to my mind as guilty. I know many have written off the over reaction and role playing and think little of it but I disagree and think him a good initial EW pick for wolf but turned out to be far too over reactionary. He's one of my prime suspects today.
Oddwen--Her behavior is similar to Sleepy and Glirdan but she's been a bit more odd when she is present than the others. Still not too much to go on.
Feanor--I always think she is guilty too, just like Kath. She's nigh impossible to ever fully understand what she is thinking and is so mauderous that I have difficulty assessing her.
Zali--If a wolf a careless wolf, if innocent a careless innocent.
Jenny Hallu--My poor unwed daughter. I have the feeling that she could be an excellent wolf and good EW another 'uncertain pile'
Lalaith--Always cool and collected. Had some rule questions which always make me wonder if it's an attempt to throw us of her scent. Helpful but good at deception.
Eonwe--See Sleepy and Glirdan for an explination.
Eomer--Another that is always guilty in my mind (See: Fea and Kath) so I cannot do a objective analysis. I had some legitimate concerns about him and used them earlier but it was part of my ruse to get reaction. His responses to that made me feel him innocent.
There are 4 or 5 from whom I'd like to hear more (and others less
). I feel that we are getting to that stage when everybody need to be less quiet and give a couple of posts a day and ensure that you vote too.