Quote:
|
Kath, as far as I understand the rules, Naria wouldn't know that Nogrod was a fellow wolf. She might have guessed, of course...is that what you mean?
|
No, that was me forgetting the rules and assuming the wolves knew who the others were and could PM
I've been reading through, and it seems that the main suspicions at the moment are falling on
Eomer and
Celuien. So:
Eomer - the case against him began well. All those quotes from posts that
mormegil dredged up could indeed be seen as suspicious, and I can quite believe
Eomer being bold enough to pull a stunt like that. However,
morm put almost no analysis of these quotes in, seemingly relying on his earlier post as explanation. Some of the charges seemed a little overly nitpicking, such as the icon theory. *sigh* And now I find that was all an elaborate ruse. Lucky I hadn't got too far along this train of thought.
Celuien - overly defensive after very little suspicion had been thrown her way. Often a reason to look out for people and I see no reason why that shouldn't be the same for her. The vote for
Alcarillo clears her a little in my eyes though, as he has been acting very oddly. The problem is I'm still assuming the wolves know each other's identities, and so think
Celuien innocent because I think
Alcarillo more likely to be a wolf, and think
Celuien would not be so bold as to vote for a fellow wolf so early. But that all depends on the wolves knowing who the other's are, if they don't that theory all goes to pot.
And may I add another to the list?
Nilp has been behaving most oddly. I know he usually abandons the whole vote for yourself, random madness stuff after Day 1, but he barely even did it Day 1. I don't know if this is out of respect for
Roa (or her ancestors even, see the latest lorebook for why on that) but it usually signifies that he is something other than an ordo. Then there was post 383, where he uses the term 'you' to refer to the villagers the whole time. I don't know it just caught me as odd. Why say 'you' and not 'we'?
And now we have
Eomer's argument for
Fea being the EW. It's an ok theory. The repeated pointing out that she wouldn't have the time is fair enough, as is the fact that had she the time she'd love to do it. If there was only some real evidence I might be more inclined to believe this one.
Who was it that said I didn't seem entirely committed to this? Was that you
Cailin? If it's any help I am committed, I just find it hard to keep up!