Quote:
|
Originally Posted by Eomer
Hmm? There are numerous clues (which I'm not sure, come to think of it, the EW would leave — unless, as Mormegil suspects, the EW is extremely brash).
|
Correct! And there are only a few among us who would be that brazen to try. You of course are one as I would consider Fea.
Currently I think Spawn is innocent as her contributions are helpful and meaningful.
Cailin also seems to fit into that mold.
I hate that we must always say currently but as the dynamic is such we must remember that people may change from one day to the next.
I am glad to see that we have others thinking for themselves and not merely following the early/easy theory because that is what it is. I placed it early and made it fairly easy for a couple of reasons.
1. I have legitimate concerns over Eomer, but I always do because he can pull off things like this bluff so I will never give him the benefit of my doubt.
2. I wanted to see who would take my theory and run with it, obvioulsy Azaelia is the worst offender there. I think there could be some merit to my theory but I'm not convinced myself that it is true.
3. I wanted to see who would resisit it and who would say nothing as that would tell us something as well. I think Gurthang's response speaks highly of him and shows that he is a critical thinker.
I'm not saying that others who agreed with me, Firefoot, in particular, are not critical thinkers as I find myself often agreeing with theories but there are those who won't do any investigation themselves and we found at least one here.
Basically I'm neither convinced of Eomer's innocence nor his guilt but wanted to get something going today.
Alcarillo is still bothering me and I'm wary of him.