I was in desperate need of a suspect / impressions list for myself, since I fear I am losing overview. So here it is:
Diamond -
Voted: Loki, Nogrod
She has said a lot these past few days, and not everything is relevant. However, she appears to be genuine. I do believe that the wizard who chose Nogrod, Naria and Loki might have picked Diamond18 to be his/her wolf as well. However, I am inclined to say she's innocent. Noteworthy that she voted for the winning candidate on both days.
Celuien -
Voted: Lommy and Lalaith
Another one who speaks a lot, yet slightly more suspicious than Diamond. In hindsight, her votes do seem a little odd. Lalaith is explainable at that time but though she provided a rather extended analysis of Lommy before voting for her, I don't think it was very reasonable. However, twas Day one, so who is reasonable then?
There is something about her that makes me uncomfortable. I am not putting the wizard past the frog, if you get my meaning.
Caranlondien -
Voted: Loki, Nogrod
There is less information on Caran. She has posted regularly, but said less than some and even her voting pattern underlines her inclination to go with the crowd. She was suspicious of Lommy, yesterDay, as well. She has been clarifying things, tallying votes but provided few theories of her own. I do not think her particularly guilty, but not very innocent either. She might just be a little overwhelmed.
Roa Aoife -
Voted: Nogrod.
What a fierce attack on Nogrod and what a victory indeed. Roa has played a remarkably clean game so far: voting twice for the wolf and defending the innocent. She is not cleared yet. This game is far too dynamic to believe her innocent. I do think it is unlikely she is the Evil Wizard, though, which is good in itself.
Dancing Spawn of Ungoliant -
Voted: Lhuna, Oddwen
Spawn has been able to remain inconspicuous. Her analysis has been less involved, but this is a large village and dynamics are completely different. Voices of reason seem usually rather lost in our situation.
However, I must admit that both Spawn's votes seem a little 'throwaway' in the masses. YesterDay, I myself was too stubborn to believe Nogrod could be a wolf (bad quality of mine) because I would not have made him a wolf. I can hardly judge people who did the same as me. But I am going to keep a closer eye on Spawn. She is different, somehow. Yet also no primary suspect.
Kath -
Voted: Lommy, Nogrod
Now I am pretty sure Kath is not a wizard. That can be ascribed to one of these feeling thingies, but also because she is seemingly not quite committed to the game. She would be my choice for a wolf, which is why I continue to regard her with some suspicion. However, her short posts are rather to the point. I'd wish to seem some more thoughts from Kath, but she might just be innocent after all. (No! She must be guilty! She must be!)
Lommy -
Voted: Nogrod
Why do people suspect Lommy? Because she has a tendency for drawing negative attention. Sorry Lom. I must agree with what Eomer said in the first place: the EW must be mad to choose Lommy as one of his wolves. However, the EW is certainly criminally insane (Nilp after all?) and he might have done it. I think not, however. I think Lommy is innocent.
Lhunardawen -
Voted: Eomer, no vote.
Lhuna, where art thou?
She might be wolvish. I'd vote Eomer if I were a wolf. In other words, I am clueless.
Glirdan -
Voted: Oddwen, no vote.
Well, Glirdan is gone I believe. He is also no wizard. Nor a wolf. I am quite convinced of it. It is strange that there has been no bandwagon against him as of yet and maybe we should start one for tradition's sake.
Valier -
Voted: Loki, Oddwen
Personally I greatly respect Valier as an asset for the good side, since she does have the most unnatural instinct for pointing out evil wherever it may try to hide. Currently, her instincts are either failing her or she has already been recruited for the forces of evil. I will have to see how she continues contributing toDay.
Sleepy Ranger -
Voted: no one, Fea.
Another silent one. Extremely silent, I might add. I cannot say much about him.
Kitanna -
Voted: Loki, Nogrod
Some great contributions yesterDay. As I hope she will marry my son before this ordeal is over, I wish to believe her innocent. She would, however, be a good pick for the EW. I am giving her the benefit of the doubt.
Firefoot -
Voted: Lommy, Roa
She defended Nogrod almost passionately yesterDay. I think she is likely innocent. Actually, she is far too adorable to believe her capable of any mischief. In short: her defense of Nogrod even after he was doomed and her continuously helpful contributions convince me that she has the village's best interests at heart.
Alcarillo -
Voted: Nogrod
My husband… yes, indeed, he does not say much. He is a good listener though. Has to be, after having been married to me for so long. I do not find him as suspicious as some, mainly because I do not think his defensiveness -though that is definitely noteworthy- nor his in character posts to be so wolvish. Be assured, however, that I shall be watching him very closely. Just one misstep and…
Cailín -
Voted: Oddwen.
I can hardly analyse myself. I am innocent, though.
Oddwen -
Voted: no vote, Lalaith
Yes, I find her silence and unhelpful behaviour highly suspicious, as can be gathered from my votes. I still cannot excuse her; she remains high up on my suspect list.
mormegil -
Voted: Kath, Nogrod
He seems a little less rash in his conclusions concerning guilt and innocence than usual, and I like that. His case against Eomer toDay was reasonable and brave to put forward and he has been right a lot so far. I cannot discount him as a possible wolf or wizard, but I think he might just be innocent. Since I tend to suspect Mormegil no matter what, I might not be all that reliable.
Feanor -
Voted: Loki, Roa
Isn't Fea wonderful? Her votes are totally off and yet she appears more innocent than anyone in this village does. I regret objecting to having her in my family at all. Well, anyway, she comes across as an innocent, though I have heard rumours that she can easily hide her evil nature. She is not my primary suspect.
I am still not discounting her as the Evil Wizard, though.
Zali -
Voted: Loki, Nogrod, Eomer
Hmm Zali… I am sorry I have to accuse you of anything right after phantom, whom you clearly adored, died, but you are starting to worry me somewhat. Yes, you did vote for Nogrod, but only after he was (practically) already doomed. Same goes for Loki. And now you just jump up at Mormegil's theory -not only that- if you are mistaken, he is to blame. That is a bit weird. However, considering the lorebooks… you are always suspicious.
Jenny Hallu -
Voted: Saucepan Man, no vote
JennyHallu is also slowly rising on my suspicious list. She has not said much yesterDay, which makes me hesitant to judge her, but I know she'd be a clever pick for the EW and she has done nothing that really speaks for her innocence. I also find it interesting that her vote for the Saucepan Man on Day 1 was more or less ignored by the crowd.
Lalaith -
Voted: Loki, Oddwen
Lalaith is a very clever woman, we all know that. Despite the fact that she appears to be helpful and thoughtful as usual, I find something a bit different about her. I am sorry, Lal, but I continue to find you a little suspicious. Her canon fodder theory has been the topic of discussion for quite a while now, but I don't find anything odd about it. I do find it a little odd that she decided Loki fit that description.
Eonwe -
Voted: Nilp, no vote
Silent, silent. Unlikely evil.
Eomer -
Voted: Nogrod
Oh dear. Eomer, promise your mum you haven't meddled with dark forces. Promise? Please? (in other words: as usual, I have difficulties judging which side Eomer is on. I see the sense behind Mormegil's words, but when I personally scrutinize Eomer's posts, I come up with nothing. He might have an unhealthy obsession for wizardry, but is that enough to condemn him?)
Nilpaurion -
Voted: Nogrod, Valier
Phantom believed Nilp might have been a wizard. I do not. His lack of voting for himself is noteworthy, but I ascribe that to him being happily married for once. I do not trust him at all, but who could?
Quote:
I'm pretty confident about my vote, though.
++Nogrod
|
I am quoting this because I found it very interesting indeed, especially because the vote was not repeated the Day after.
Gurthang -
Voted: Lommy, Nogrod
He is a little silent and I am not used to that. Still, I find no reason to particularly suspect him as of yet.
--
Wow, that took me quite a while. At least I do not think I missed anyone this time.