Quote:
|
Originally Posted by Nogrod
If Glirdan was a goose, he totally disregarded Spm's warnings about "bad goose tactics" and did exactly what Spm thought really bad...?
|
An interesting point you make. Yet, I wasn't saying that the "Goose tactic" I outlined would necessarily be bad. It would depend on the circumstances. I said that, if anyone claimed to be the Owl, then they should be believed as, if they were a Goose, they would swiftly be found out. But it might be worth the Goose doing this, for example in an attempt to expose the real Owl. That is not the situation which occured. But I still believe that Glirdan (the Goose) thought spawn to be innocent and that her death, together with the confusion caused, was worth his own.
If I am wrong, it means that Mith must have been the Goose. In which case, we can no longer rely on Valier's innocence. The possibility that Valier may be the last Duck is almost too dreadful to contemplate.
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by mormegil
However their behavior pattern was consistent in the way they treated the other ducks.
|
No. Their behaviour pattern was consistent in the way they treated
Ducks and innocents alike. I really don't see how this point counts against Kath, morm, and your persistence with it strengthens my concerns over you.