[The Saucepan Man]

Originally Posted by mormegil

SpM you speak fair sense and it helps allay any doubt that you were converted on night 2. Well my good SpM what do you propose? I still think Kath highly suspect and want her lynched. I really would like to hear a bit more from Valier, as she is the only one I trust 100%

When you said I spoke sense, I presume that you were referring to my comment about the dangers of focussing too much on you and Kath. Yet you continue to display a single-minded determination to see Kath lynched without considering other possibilities. If you are innocent, you muct surely recognise the possibility that Kath is too. And you must surely see the danger then inherent in your approach. We lynch one of you today and (when that person is proven innocent) automatically lynch the other tomorrow. And lose.

Your single-mindedness in this regard points more to your guilt than your innocence, in my view.

Originally Posted by Valier

I am leaning towards Kath and more so Cailin at the moment, I still find it odd that she is no where to be seen yet today.

Originally Posted by Nogrod

I agree with Spm, that (non-)Cailin is really dangerously quiet.

The possibility that Calin is a Duck concerns me greatly. If she is, then she almost deserves to win. But, as I said earlier, it is often easier for the werecreature, with the knowledge he or she has, to appear innocent than it is for the true innocents to appear as such. I speak from experience (on both "sides of the fence") on this.

Originally Posted by Nogrod

Now someone said, I might be the goose here. I admit I have tried to add complexity to our choices, but not with the idea of misguiding us, but for us to see the real possibilities.

I think that you may be referring to my earlier comment. I said that your speculation that Mith may have been the Goose may have been calculated to cause confusion. By this, I meant not that you might be the Goose, but that you might well be our remaining Duck. I believe our Goose to be dead, courtesy of Ang. You describe the likelihood of you being the Duck as being small. But it is not. You were declared innocent as the result of a Night 1 dream. It remains quite possible that the Ducks tried to kill you on Night 2. In fact, you were a quite likely target for them.

Originally Posted by Nogrod

Good that you took that up Kath. I was wondering, should I check, were there others with over-rounded opinions in Jenny's post. Somehow Morm didn't manage to point all the cases out, just those suiting his purposes - as happened on his first post on dAY2...

I made the point myself earlier, although perhaps not quite so forcefully:

Originally Posted by me

I am not sure that we should read too much into Jenny's post that you refer to, as she mentioned a number of people, innocents and Ducks alike, in a fairly neutral way.

Morm seems to be a serial offender when it comes to selecting excerpts from quotes to suit his arguments ...