davem, or you're just like me and I just gave up a long time ago and shake my head yes to whatever you have to say.
Welcome to the forum
Goldberry and I agree. I don't think Tolkien would have made a good director (especially now adays) looking at his stance on certain quarrels he had with Zimmerman's screenplay...but I think it's clear that Tolkien would have had issues with many things PJ did, several of them which he criticized Zimmerman for doing.