Ok so now the list shortens again...
Known Innocents
Valier
SPM
Mithalwen
Unknowns
Nogrod
Mormegil
Kath
Cailin
Lote22
I think it possible that the Ducks choose
Jenny on the second night and she was turned, she would have made a good kill for them since she was not well suspected by the village. This would leave one of the original Ducks left.
Or it could be one Mith dreamt of earlier...
I think either
Kath or
Mormegil is the remaining Duck
I will read through the posts and see what I can come up with.... I will be back in a bit