OKay, I got home 45 minutes ago, and it has taken me all that time to just read through everything. To answer
Saucie's request for more analysis- I like to hold my analysis until later in the game, when there are fewer players, or when the players can be broken into groups for more detail. I like detail. A lot.
I like to give the quiet people the benefit of the doubt on Day 1. Sometimes people just need to get into the swing of things. And who knows? Maybe if we let Nilp live, he'll be useful. If he pulls the same stunt tomorrow, I'll probably vote for him, and advocate his banishment from Werewolf. (People like that just take up space and make the game less fun. And if he is a Duck, I find it terribly unsporting and he should be ashamed of himself.) Also, this random vote thing has been Sleepy's deal for the past few games, therianthrope or not. Actually, in the games where he was the enemy he attempted helpfulness on Day 1. So if anything, I think this lowers him on the suspect list.
I finally realized what seemed wierd to me about Nogrod. In the past few games he's been toning down his agression. Now it's suddenly back at it's full peak, including his agression towards anyone (namely me) who didn't agree with him. Strange, did he just decide to drop his (albeit relatively) subdued manner in the passion of his argument? Or is he just being a bold Duck?
Mith, I honestly don't see what you're getting upset at me over. I never said it was a high suspicion. I was just throwing things out, trying to get a bite. You bit quite well, I might add. I understand your current issues, so I'll let it go. Also, having worked with in wolfish behavior, I doubt you would be this jumpy if you really were a Duck. I'll let you slide today, but your look at Spawn seemed to be grasping at straws.
Glirdan strikes me as odd. Note that in
this post he seemed to address all questions raised in his direction without actually answering them. Really, it was just more nonsense, and I know he's capable of more.
As a note to all villagers, please remember this is a game, and taking too much offense to what's being said is rather silly and childish. In the same token, please try not to be insulting or condescending in your posts (ie using words like stupid, etc...)
Edit: Corss posted with Kath and Sleepy.