View Single Post
Old 04-19-2006, 05:48 PM   #426
Grendelien
Haunting Spirit
 
Grendelien's Avatar
 
Join Date: Mar 2006
Location: flat-point high
Posts: 52
Grendelien has just left Hobbiton.
I was suspicious of Naria before she revealed Nogrod's innocence, and upon revealing his identity I thought her revelation could be a diversion. However, I began to wonder why, if she were an orc, she would reveal the identity of someone who was under much suspicion himself. It could be that she was protecting the identity of a fellow orc, but I find this highly unlikely. I tend to believe now that Nogrod is innocent. If Naria is an orc, I find it unlikely that she would reveal the identity of an innocent (Nogrod) when he was under suspicion. However, Naria could want to gain some points with innocent villagers. I'll have to think about this more. My suspicion of her has been lowered a bit, so I won't be voting for her tonight.

The points brought up about Celuien in the analyses of her were very interesting. I too must admit that her change in tone is suspicious, but I dont want to vote for her tonight when she's not here to defend herself.

I'm unsure of Findeasea's and Caranlondien's innocence, so I won't vote for them tonight. My suspicion of Roa has not changed, so I am inclined to believe she may be an orc.

++Roa
Grendelien is offline   Reply With Quote