Quote:
|
Originally Posted by Findeasea
Roa: I should have phrased my post a lot better. I didn’t mean that you do not contribute or state your opinions, but that your apparent helpfulness might be a distraction from giving away actual opinions which might put you in a guilty light. Hmm… I still feel like what I am trying to say is not coming out right. The best way I can think to phrase what I mean is that the root of your contributions is not exactly clear to me.
I am sorry if I called you suspicious falsely, but I just didn’t want to risk not saying anything in case my feeling was right.
|
Suspecting people is part of the game. (Right now the only person I don't at least midly suspect is Sleepy.) There are no hards feeling over that. I don't understand what you're saying though- I'm contributing, helping the village, definitely stating my opinions, and that makes me more suspicios? By that reasoning, Nogrod and Celuien are also highly suspicious. Please explain why I'm standing out.
Nogrod- I've found another flaw in your plan. What if Diamond was the one dreamt of last night? What if Spawn was the one dreamt of by the Shaman first? That would certainly throw a kink in your plans. For someone who accused Spawn of spreading Orcish propaganda, you seem to come up with a lot of faulty plans yourself.
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by Celuien
*pinches self*
Still alive. I didn't expect that at all. I really thought that either Zali or I would be toast last night. Still, it's good to be here.
|
Why didn't you think Sleepy would die?
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by Grendelien
I've been thinking very long and hard about who the possible Shaman could be. I have a thought, based on posts (I'm sorry this is terribly, annoyingly vague, but I think it's crucial to protect the identity of the possible Shaman), and if it turns out to be somehow miraculously correct, I believe the innocence of some unknown villagers may be confirmed.
There would be three remaining ones that I would still be unsure of- Naria, Roa, and Caranlondien.
I'm definitely not going to suspect these three right away, because I know that my thought on who the Shaman is may be very, very wrong, and therefore detrimental to the village. Unfortunately, I won't know if my thoughts are correct unless the Shaman is exposed or killed, and I'd rather be wrong than have that happen. Since I know that I could very well be wrong in my guess, I'm not going to accuse any of the three right away...but I will keep myeye on them.
|
I'm curious to know how you can narrow the list down so far. There have only been four nights, therefore only four dreams. One of those was of an Orc, so that leaves only 3 dreams, another was of Sleepy, so that's 2 to reveal known innocents. One was just the previous night, and the dreamer may not have arrived yet, so you really only have one to go on, from the first day. In regular games, dreams go directly to the seer, and even then, if the seer dies, we can't always interpret their posts properly. If a seer thinks someone is innocent, that doesn't mean they dreamt of them. Likewise, if a seer thinks someone is suspicious, it doesn't make them guilty. So, how, in this game, when the dreams don't necessarily go to the Shaman, are you able to narrow the list so far down, just by figuring out who the Shaman is?