The Barrow-Downs Discussion Forum - View Single Post - Tol-in-Gaurhoth XX: Wereorc I: The elves cannot hide themselves much longer.

Celuien · 04-17-2006, 02:50 PM

I don't want to vote so early and after having been so relatively quiet today (RL got busy today), but I'm going to have to due to that rehearsal I was talking about lasting until about an hour after the day ends.

++ KITANNA

I'm willing to trust Diamond on this for today, as my suspect has gone up in smoke.

I'm not sure why Sleepy felt compelled to announce that he thinks I'm the Shaman. It's strange, and but for the dream announcing his innocence, I'd have added it to evidence for his being an Orc. I hope that plan of his is working out the way it's supposed to if he's innocent. (Actually, I can think of one reason for innocent-Sleepy to do it, but if he genuinely thinks I'm the Shaman, it doesn't work.)

Ugh. I case I don't survive the night, here's where I was going with Sleepy/Nogrod:

1) Nogrod as an Orc who did receive the dream about Sleepy.
1a) Sleepy is also an Orc and Nogrod used the dream (knowing it would be confirmed as a dream) to show his colleague's 'innocence.' They then planned to out the Shaman the next day with the confirmed innocent of the pair.
1b) Nogrod is an Orc using the dream of an innocent Sleepy as cover. This argument has already been made.

For the options under section 1, I actually think 1a would be the more likely. I'm still a bit perturbed over the 'Celuien is the Shaman' stuff.

2) Nogrod and Sleepy are both innocent.

For the record: This the the theory I currently accept, just because I've been inclined (even without dream evidence) to trust him from the beginning because his behavior has felt innocent to me. But, it's entirely possible that I'm wrong, so, if I'm dead tomorrow, because 1a is plausible, please look in to it for me.

See you in the morning, I hope.

04-17-2006, 02:50 PM	#288
Celuien Riveting Ribbiter Join Date: May 2005 Location: Assigned to Mordor Posts: 1,767	I don't want to vote so early and after having been so relatively quiet today (RL got busy today), but I'm going to have to due to that rehearsal I was talking about lasting until about an hour after the day ends. ++ KITANNA I'm willing to trust Diamond on this for today, as my suspect has gone up in smoke. I'm not sure why Sleepy felt compelled to announce that he thinks I'm the Shaman. It's strange, and but for the dream announcing his innocence, I'd have added it to evidence for his being an Orc. I hope that plan of his is working out the way it's supposed to if he's innocent. (Actually, I can think of one reason for innocent-Sleepy to do it, but if he genuinely thinks I'm the Shaman, it doesn't work.) Ugh. I case I don't survive the night, here's where I was going with Sleepy/Nogrod: 1) Nogrod as an Orc who did receive the dream about Sleepy. 1a) Sleepy is also an Orc and Nogrod used the dream (knowing it would be confirmed as a dream) to show his colleague's 'innocence.' They then planned to out the Shaman the next day with the confirmed innocent of the pair. 1b) Nogrod is an Orc using the dream of an innocent Sleepy as cover. This argument has already been made. For the options under section 1, I actually think 1a would be the more likely. I'm still a bit perturbed over the 'Celuien is the Shaman' stuff. 2) Nogrod and Sleepy are both innocent. For the record: This the the theory I currently accept, just because I've been inclined (even without dream evidence) to trust him from the beginning because his behavior has felt innocent to me. But, it's entirely possible that I'm wrong, so, if I'm dead tomorrow, because 1a is plausible, please look in to it for me. See you in the morning, I hope. __________________ People assume that time is a strict progression of cause to effect. But actually, from a non-linear, non-subjective viewpoint, it's more like a big ball of wibbly-wobbly, timey-wimey... stuff.