I agree that Caranlondien should not be one of the lynchees. She feels innocent to me.
I'm still not convinced that you guys want to do a double lynch toDay, not as long as there are two werewolves out there. Even though I doubt Samwise is innocent, I don't want to see the village risking another double lynch of innocents.
If you lynch just Samwise and he turns out to be innocent, there are still 9 villagers tomorrow, with still more voting record. If he turns out to be a werewolf, as I expect, then with three known innocents left, plus such redoubtably believable villagers such as tar-ancalime and maybe even Caranolondien, the chances for the werewolves will look slim indeed.
Uh oh, just had an awful thought. What if tar has been doing an incredible job of pulling the wool over all our eyes?

Ack! Stop that, LMP! One lynchee at a time, I say!