[Gurthang]

Okay, so my conclusions.

Appeared on the suspicious lists:

Caranlondien - 1, 2, 3, 4
Naria - 1, 4
Valier - 1, 3, 4
LMP - 1, 2
Thinlomien - 2
Lalaith - 2, 4
SamwiseGamgee - 2, 3
Gurthang - 2
tar-ancalime - 3

Appeared on the innocent lists:

Cailín - 1, 2
Formendacil - 1, 2, 3, 4
SamwiseGamgee - 1, 4
tar-ancalime - 2, 4
Valier - 2
Naria - 2, 3
Lalaith - 3
LMP - 3

So, in order from most suspicious to least:

1. Caranlondien (4,0)
2. Valier (3, 1)
3. LMP (2,1)
3. Lalaith (2,1)
5. Naria (2,2)
5. Samwise (2,2)
7. Gurthang (1,0)
7. Thinlomien (1,0)
9. tar-ancalime (1,2)
10. Cailin (0,2)
11. Formendacil (0,4)