Okay, I was on Day Three, post #416...
Post #416, continued
Says perhaps werewolves took advantage of
Eonwe's situation on Day Two (he had trouble getting to a computer), and took advantage of that to lynch him.
Summarizes what the dead innocent said that we still aren't sure of:
Garin thinks
Cailín is innocent
Anguirel defends
Cailín against
Samwise;
LMP points suspicion to
Glirdan, since
Anguirel voted for him.
Makes another list, which you can go back and read if you want; It's too much to try to summarize his summaries!
DAY FOUR
Post #417
Analyzes
Spawn's posts for clues.
Post #418
Says
Eomer,
TGWBS, and
Farael have all sown confusion. We now know that
none of these people were wolves, although
Farael was a Lover.
Says that
Kath is worthy of "having an eye kept on her", but right now all the noise about her is a distraction from the more obvious candidate,
Lhuna. Says
TGBWS's suggestion that
Spawn did NOT dream of
Lhuna is "garbage".
Post #419
Rejects
TGWBS's plan.
Post #423
Corrects himself about
Lhuna's Day One vote.
Post #424
Says perhaps
Lhuna's response to
TGWBS's plan ("it makes me think you are the sole male wolf") is close to the truth - perhaps there are 3 females and 1 male wolf. Suggests we double-lynch
TGWBS with
Lhuna instead of
Kath. Trying to shift suspicion away from
Kath? Possibly...
Post #426
Responds to me saying I would support a
TGWBS lynching.
Post #429
Realizes he can't rely on
Lhuna to help lynch
TGWBS, and so votes for
Lhuna.
Explains his suspicions of
Eomer and
TGWBS. Mild accusation against
Formendacil for defending
Lhuna and accusing
Kath. Continues to think all the talk of
Kath is a distraction.
Quote:
I think tar-ancalime, Caranlondien, Thinlomien, Samwise, & Farael are probably innocent. I think that Gurthang & Cailín are probably not werewolves either. I'm not sure about Valier, Lalaith, Glirdan, Kath, Naria, & Celuien. I'm really suspicious of Formendacil, Eomer, & Guy. And I think Lhunardawen is so furry it must hurt
|
DAY FOUR
Post #479
Agrees with
Lalaith's suspicions of
TGWBS. Calls
Cailin "one of the more suspicious based on voting records." Responds to
Lalaith (who said she was most suspicious of
Formendacil,
TGWBS, and
LMP) by saying that a healthy analysis of all three should point her in the right direction.
Post #481
Agrees with
Cailin that we shouldn't put any stock in what
Lhuna said at the end of Day Three. Says he is suspicious of
TGWBS. Asks
Lalaith to post more to allay suspicions of her.
Post #482
Agrees with
tar-a that we should look at
Glirdan.
Post #485
Thinks
Farael may have let something slip in his desperation.
Post #522
Posts chart of votes. Concludes
TGWBS is a werewolf, and makes conjectures about others' innocence based on
TGWBS's assumed guilt.
Post #532
Responds to a point raised in my analysis of
Farael, and says maybe
TGWBS isn't a wolf. Thinks more, then says maybe he
is a wolf.
Post #533
Agrees with
TGWBS that double-lynches favor the innocents.
Post #534
Correction / joke
Post #550
Defends
tar-a's post as not seeming contradictory to him. Agrees that
Lhuna voters are not automatically innocent.
Post #551
Continues to think
TGWBS is guilty, and votes for him. Makes a "just for the record" post of who he thinks is guilty / not guilty.
DAY FIVE
Post #574
Now thinks
Lhuna voters are more likely to be guilty.
Post #591
Analyzes everyone based on several factors; conclude
Samwise,
Caranlondien, and
LMP look the most suspicious (but exempts himself since he "knows he's innocent").
Points out that perhaps double lynches should not continue, since we no longer have a large number-advantage.
Conclusion:
I keep asking myself why
LMP is still alive. A lot of us have been inclined to trust him. This is bordering on dangerous territory, but he is definitely clever enough to fool us all through an implied masquerade. I'm just not sure about him, and I have to think.
I'll be back in a bit