Wow! This looks like a pretty fun game. Lots of funny stuff from people.
The choice between Elrond and Fimbrethil seems pretty clear cut to me, though. Just look at the way they felt about their significant other.
Elrond- He did everything he could to heal his wife so she could stay with him in Middle Earth. Unfortunately for him, it didn't work out.
Fimbrethil- She just picked up and left her mate, and never came back.
Honestly, how cold is that? Then again, what do you expect from an overgrown stick?
++Fimbrethil