As I said above, I don't see how the game can continue the way the votes are being counted (or not counted
) without being a sham, so I hope,
Form, that you will either agree to count all votes
or make it clear which votes you are counting and which votes you are not. Also the "criteria" as to what is Tolkien enough or not Tolkien enough should be made crystal clear and should not change from round to round.
But that is in reference to the future. What is now past ought to be fixed.
My suggestion at the moment is this: either reinstate Khamul and evict Celeborn, or reinstate Oropher and evict Elrond. Because you cannot have it both ways without admitting that you are not playing fair with us. I know it's a bold suggestion, but we have all invested a bit of time and thought into this game, so I hope you don't mean to claim full power.
I'm going out on a limb here, but I think the recent tabulations merit a bit of an outcry.