Quote:
|
Originally Posted by the phantom
Next, we have Dancing Spawn come along and cast her vote for Elrond, proving that she is much prettier than she is intelligent. Her reasoning is that Elrond wasn't a success in a previous season of Survivor. What kind of non-reason is that? And then she gives another reason- that anyone could have founded Rivendell with the power of Vilya. There, she is showing her stupidity. Elrond did not have Vilya when he founded Rivendell. At that time, Vilya was still with Gil-galad.
|
Really now? You just know how to compliment a girl, don't you?
Interesting that you should pick me to accuse of having insufficient reasons to vote for
Elrond when just yesterday there was a bunch of people throwing their votes around because of the word 'camel'. I don't remember you expressing your disapproval to see people voting Khamûl based on that, and yet today you say that you are disappointed with
JennyHallu. Her vote for Elrond was just as good as any of those that were cast for Khamûl.
However, I shall forgive you speaking rashly because for some reason you seem to be attached to Elrond and your feelings are clearly slowing your thoughts. If I may quote the Encyclopedia of Arda:
Quote:
|
It [Vilya] was originally held by Gil-galad, but he passed it to Elrond at the time of the founding of Rivendell.
|
As to the 'non-reason', I said that Elrond wasn't great in the last shows, and then I took a look at his doings in the 2nd Age. My conclusion was: nothing special this time either. When you add that to the list, I don't see why to keep him around.