The Barrow-Downs Discussion Forum - View Single Post - Tol-in-Gaurhoth XVIII: The Play’s The Thing…

mormegil · 02-28-2006, 05:26 PM

I did some reviewing of Aiwendil, the last few post of yesterday didn't sit right with me.

On DAY 3 he voted 12th for Garin thus equalizing the number of votes that Garin and Eomer had at 2. Nobody else had above 1. Also Eomer still hadn't voted. That's fairly suspicious but then DAY 4 Aiwendil is 7th for tar-a which was her 3rd vote, again this tied up the vote for Eomer. It also came right after Kath and Eomer. It appears that Aiwendil tried to disguise his vote and save Eomer. If tar-a isn't a wolf, which I'm not sure of I think Aiwendil might be. Regardless I think he's worth looking at.

One thing is that I believe we should focus heavily on those who didn't vote for Eomer. Specifically:

Tar-a
Kath
Aiwnedil
Celuien
Glirdan (no vote)

Those who did vote for Eomer are generally believe to be innocent

Formendacil (innocent)
Mormegil (innocent)[/B]SpM--3rd vote putting Eomer clearly in the lead
Nilp--started voting for Eomer.

Now out of those Nilp and SpM aren't fully innocent in my mind but I tend to believe in their innocence currently.

Formendacil, how much will you be able to be around toDAY? I think you are a key piece in our chance for victory. You can help be a voice of reason and trust.

02-28-2006, 05:26 PM	#413
mormegil Maundering Mage Join Date: Apr 2005 Location: Texas Posts: 4,651	I did some reviewing of Aiwendil, the last few post of yesterday didn't sit right with me. On DAY 3 he voted 12th for Garin thus equalizing the number of votes that Garin and Eomer had at 2. Nobody else had above 1. Also Eomer still hadn't voted. That's fairly suspicious but then DAY 4 Aiwendil is 7th for tar-a which was her 3rd vote, again this tied up the vote for Eomer. It also came right after Kath and Eomer. It appears that Aiwendil tried to disguise his vote and save Eomer. If tar-a isn't a wolf, which I'm not sure of I think Aiwendil might be. Regardless I think he's worth looking at. One thing is that I believe we should focus heavily on those who didn't vote for Eomer. Specifically: Tar-a Kath Aiwnedil Celuien Glirdan (no vote) Those who did vote for Eomer are generally believe to be innocent Formendacil (innocent) Mormegil (innocent)[/B]SpM--3rd vote putting Eomer clearly in the lead Nilp--started voting for Eomer. Now out of those Nilp and SpM aren't fully innocent in my mind but I tend to believe in their innocence currently. Formendacil, how much will you be able to be around toDAY? I think you are a key piece in our chance for victory. You can help be a voice of reason and trust. __________________ “I wish it need not have happened in my time," said Frodo. "So do I," said Gandalf, "and so do all who live to see such times. But that is not for them to decide. All we have to decide is what to do with the time that is given us.”