Post 2
His comment here could be construed as an attempt to have the hunter show him/herself prematurely.
Quote:
|
Now: I've made knives of it, a pretty little collection. Each of ye should purchase a nice silvery knife from me so as to make sure that who ever is our hunter winds up with a silvery knife. And if every last one of us has one, maybe one as is a werewolf will have bad luck and sit no its own silver knife and thereby do itself in.
|
It’s not like usual when somebody sells a weapon, they do it without naming roles. However, this seems much more like an attempt to get the Hunter to step forward and say “I’ll buy a weapon”. For the wolves it’s to their advantage to kill the Hunter as quickly as they can. That way he/she is less a liability to them than at a latter stage of the game.
Also this is the post that he started his infamous ‘seer talk’
Post 16 and 17
Quick post with no real content
Post 18
He quickly identifies himself with
Aiwendil and seemingly agrees with him. To me it seems as though he’s pushing too hard for us to find him innocent which always sets off alarms in my mind.
Post 19
Agrees with
SpM
Post 24
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by LMP
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by tar-ancalime
It seems to me we've got to play as though we'd already lost the Seer (blind, if you catch me). We can dispense with the usual Seer-related flotsam of the first few days: people looking for hints that aren't there, declaring that they know who the Seer is, silly warnings to keep hidden, and the rest of that nonsense. We've just got to do the best we can and wait for later in the game, when we'll (if we're lucky) get a great gift from the true Seer.
|
I agree. I was more or less trying to say this. Thanks for saying it better. |
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by LMP
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by tar-ancalime
I'd like to propose a moratorium on Seer talk--we can't know who is true until one of them dies, and the longer we wait the more information we'll get. So let's play as though neither of them is here.
|
The only problem with this is that seer talk is one more piece of the village talk by which we may be able to snare a werewolf by means of his/her words. So although I sympathize with your desire for clarity, too much of that kind of clarity at this early stage might help the werewolves (to hide out in the open) more than the innocents. |
It seems that he twist
Tar-ancalime’s words here doesn’t it? Basically I understood
Tar to be saying that the seer should really be quiet and not leave any major clues. Then
LMP comes in nobly and brave to say that she is requesting too much clarity from the seers and that this type can only serve the wolves. I find this entire post to be a bit odd.
Post 53
Is a response to a rebuttal of a retort of
Anguirel.
LMP comes across as being too keen to answer everything here and cover any and all tracks.
Post 54
Posts that he and
SpM never seem to agree and states that he is somewhat suspicious of him but doesn’t know why. “Things sound and look the same on the surface, but there's an undercurrent that I can't quite put my finger on, and it makes me wonder if he's furry” To me it comes across as him opening the back door for an attack on
SpM.
Post 98
Out of nowhere he comes up with his suspicion of
Boromir making it seem like he had this all along and yet never mentioned him previously and yet was around enough to post a rather large amount.
Post 99
Does a list of votes and gets mad at
Kath and
Celuien for voting for
Gil 3rd and 4th. Obvioulsy he wasn’t trying to save a fellow wolf but perhaps appear as though he thought
Gil to be innocent and wanted to save him. Yet he knew that
Boromir would have to save himself by killing
Gil.
Speaking of the
Boromir bandwagon I don’t see why it took off so quickly. I didn’t find that comment really suspicious at all, probably because that is how I felt too. Day 1 is never much fun and everything seemed to be normal. I hope to be able to look a little bit closer at
Boromir today but as it stands I think that
LMP is much more guilty than he is.
My conclusion is that
LMP is definately suspcious and most likely a wolf. If he is a wolf it's not likely that
Tar-A is because of their talk earlier. Unless there is some major change I think I will be voting for
LMP. He has posted often, many with little or no content. He seems nervous, obviously he's not the seer and I don't believe that he's another gifted. I really think his behavior is indicative of a wolf.