[Mithalwen]

Well I am back in my draughty cyber cafe, having finally escaped work.....

Hmm ... this may require a major rethink...... up to now I would have said I was most inclined to think Valier guilty, Jenny and Firefoot innocent, Elu ( like Eonwe until he was cleared) too insubstantial to pin down and Gandalf....well frankly I am fed up with Gandalf doing this again. Which is why I am still tempted to vote for him.

However, the fact that if Valier were a wolf she could have ensured her survival for another day already by voting for Jenny is a point in her favour. So I am prepared to look at her theory. Look again at Firefoot - since I was wrong about her being the seer I should look with fresh eyes and see if my initial doubts, were in fact, sound, and see if there is enough of Elu to draw conclusions on. It hadn't occured to look at Thinlomien's posts much again - I don't remember her being around much.. but here goes....