Actually, I retract my suspicion of Valier. I have been reading back through the posts and noticed that Roa voted for Valier on day 2. I am aware that this could be a wolf-on-wolf vote, but consider the heavy suspicion that had fallen on Valier at the end of Day 1. In such a light it becomes a vote that in retrospect seems to point to Roa as a wolf. A vote for someone who was already thought suspicious, but who Roa knew was innocent...very safe.
And Valier, do not be too hasty in your trust of Firefoot.
Mithalwen was the first to express suspicion of Firefoot on the first day. I jumped on that, but because of my aggressive play and silly career-based posting earlier, my analysis was discounted, as it should have been. I apologize to my fellow innocents (whether you believe I am or not) for general stupidity on my first day. On the second day, Firefoot agreed that her posts were contradictory, and told us all that was deliberate. She also told us there were no clues to be found in Thinlomian's posts, and that the wolves must have gone for someone so innocent that it could only confuse us. But read again her post 92:
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by Firefoot
I've been looking over Thinlomien's posts, and I'm not getting a whole lot out of them. She mentioned Wilwa, Sleepy, and Valier as being rather suspicious, but she said herself it was mostly a gut feeling. No one really accused her either. I think that's probably why the wolves went after her: she was pretty innocent-seeming, rather useful to the village, and she doesn't leave a trail for us to follow. I'd say that makes a sensible kill.
|
We seem to have accepted this at face value, and didn't really go back and discuss Lommy's posts. But look at Lommy's post 52:
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by Thinlomian
Firefoot is a difficult case. I say, if she isn't killed by wolves soon, she's a wolf. (Wolves seem to prefer killing the villagers that have something to say or are making themselves important for the village.) And now the wolves won't probably kill her anyway, because it serves them well to have her there under my suspicion. And on the other hand, they might think that a reason to kill her. Oh no, I'm making this meaningless babbling.
|
If Firefoot was innocent, then why did she not mention Lommy suspected her? In fact she rather cleverly turned us away from taking a closer look at the little Lommy had the chance to tell us. Firefoot then voted for Nogrod, our seer, with very little to back up her suspicion.
I am aware that Firefoot is not here, and had I found this earlier I would have brought it up earlier. But those that are, I urge you to take a look back at Firefoot's posting. I think she is currently the top of my list of suspects.