[Firefoot]

Unless Gandalf chooses to show up, we really can't do anything about him. Lynching him for silence could be disastrous, but so could not lynching him. There's nothing we can do there, so the only logical thing I can see doing is leaving him out of the calculations (still). That still means that one werewolf must be in the remaining suspects, and it narrows our list down, in however flawed a manner.

Okay, I'm dredging up bits and pieces that may or may not go together when I'm done - we'll see.

Mithalwen (Day 3)
but can we really just ignore Eonwe and Gandalf?

Based on this, I think that if Mithalwen is a wolf, Gandalf is probably innocent (we already know Eonwe is, of course). Why would a wolf bring up her fellow wolf while he's being ignored? However, if Mithalwen is innocent, this tells us nothing. The same might possibly be said of Elu as he later quoted this statement and emphatically agreed.

Roa (Day 1)
Jenny's drawn quite a bit of attention. She's agressive in her accusations, and has hopped around quite a bit, taking one lead, then changing to another. That's very wolvish, but could also signify someone new to this whole game.
...
Gandalf, well, this is his typicial behavior. As I understand it, he has limited access.
[Followed by Wilwa vote]

Could be nothing, but this is what I was talking about with reserved suspicions.

Roa (Day 3)
As for my own suspicions, I didn't want to pursue it yesterday in the interest of fairness, but I don't trust Elu. He hasn't been helpful at all, he didn't vote Day 1, he attacked Valier quite viciously on Day 2, and provided little reason for his attack except frothiness. He never came up with anything new. And his vote for Jenny yesterday was more than questionable. Especially since after he voted for her, he said he wouldn't accuse her out right. I understand the time contraints, really I do, but after the attack of Valier, to change his mind so quickly, it does draw attention.

Again, not sure what to make of this. Could be trying to cast suspicion on an innocent, could be trying to hide wolvish associations. She never mentions him again, but she had noted him as suspicious on the Day before for voting for Jenny accompanied by the comment that he wouldn't actually accuse him outright. Perhaps Elu can be tentatively cleared?

Valier (Day 2)
Roa: She agree's I've been frothy and wants to know why I post that way.Sorry it was the first day!!

It's the comments like these between Valier and Roa that seem almost too honest to be wolvishly contrived. Additionally, Roa seems to have used Valier as her scapegoat quite a bit. I'm starting to think that Valier may be innocent.

Sorry, have to go, these are sort of half-thought-out ideas. More musings later.