[dancing spawn of ungoliant]

Originally Posted by SpM

EDIT: Also, I am unsure on the legality of voting for someone who is already dead and then subsequently voting for someone else (living). Given the non-retractability rule, is it allowed? Just want to be clear whether malkatoj's (second) vote will count.

I'd appreciate if Modetarmacil could enlighten us on this matter soon. However, my broadband connection is acting really weird and I think it would be best for me to vote now while it's still working. I try to come back to discuss with you later, but I want to make sure that I can vote.

Originally Posted by Cailín

She provides excellent analyses, and yet easily skips over a few parts that would not work for her theory.

Such as?
Well, anyway, the wolves aren't plain stupid, they won't act suspiciously all the time. I pick up the things I find questionable and build a theory out of them. My theories may be right or wrong, but I hope that they'd make us more talkative.

I can't for my life understand the reason why you put mormegil and I into one group saying that we don't mention each other often enough, so I won't go into that.

Btw, did you notice, you did it again: you mentioned that you, too, find Shelob suspicious, but then left it at that and started analyzing TGWBS and Garin. Were you satisfied with my summary of Shelob? Sure you don't want to add something I skipped in order to make my theory work.

Originally Posted by Sauce

True, he would act suicidal whether innocent or a Wolf

No, he wouldn't. (Although I guess that's not enough for a defense in a court.)

Ah, I can't decide yet whom I should vote for. I'll take the risk and leave voting for later till more people have said something.