[The Saucepan Man]

Originally Posted by Shelob

Um, not that I can see. The timing doesn't really play into it so far as I can tell.

At that time, quite a bit of suspicion had already been cast in Wayne's direction, if not towards Valier. My point is that it's possible Glirdan, if he is a Wolf, has subtly been trying to direct the voting towards one or more of these three without actually voting for any of them himself. Another point to note is that he said that he would probably not be voting for me but rather for one of his other suspects (Valier or Wayne) - but then ended up voting for me. A vote which I have already noted might be seen as a "safe" vote for a Wolf to cast.

I admit that it's not much by itself, but it's something to add to the pot.

Originally Posted by Valier

But I don't like the part about a vote or reasons for a vote have to be valid because we would only find out that there reason was valid if they voted correctly and lynched a wolf.

Ah, I get your meaning and it's a fair point. By "valid", I meant something with some kind of substance to it - something more, for example, than just voting for someone because of the way they are behaving when they always act like that, or voting for someone based on their occupation.