[The Saucepan Man]

Originally Posted by Gil-Galad

i beleive in what Mr. Saucey-Judge-Man is saying, and we should maybe respect his Authoritay

The Man of Shapes speaks sense, though the images which he conjures before us sorely confuse me. I am nevertheless heartened that he at least is prepared to put his trust in the law.

Well, if no one else is to bring a forensic mind to bear in this most dire of situations, I suppose I shall have to do so myself and act in the role of both prosecutor and judge.

WaynetheGoblin, please stand forth and answer me these questions.

You suspect Formendacil because he voted early. Yet you have voted early yourself. Does not that make you suspicious on the basis of your own words?

And you voiced suspicion of him as the Cobbler, yet vote for him as though you believe him to be a Wolf. Why?

And now, Miss OfRohan. You voice mistrust of lawyers, yet seek to bring accusations yourself and call upon three of our fellow villagers to defend themselves.

Originally Posted by AbercrombieofRohan

Doing some careful sleuthing work (pulling names out of a hat), I have deduced that Formendacil, Aiwendil and Gil-Galad are guilty.

The law decrees that all are innocent until proven guilty. Please enlighten us as to the evidence upon which you base these accusations.