Obloquy said that Luthien was the greatest Eldar meaning she had the most potent spirit; And I can agree to that, since she was half maia. But she is not the greatest craftsman, or warrior, and my point is, that is for each reader to decide whom they think it is. Tolkien disliked allegory, because it was something the writer decided, not the reader; I think he would agree that each reader should read the books carefully, and study them, so that he may decide for himself, instead of taking on quote and then never think of it again. The discussions that we have about the greatest elf encourages everyone to consider whom they think should be considered, and why, thus making them studying the books more.
PS: Don't point out people's spelling errors unless it is so disturbing you don't understand the meaning, many don't have english as their native language, and it isn't fun for them to have their mistakes pointed out.
__________________
Two beer or not two beer, that is the question; by Shakesbeer
|