Quote:
|
it was the 'all honest souls' part that caught my attention.
|
If you didn’t have a problem with the idea, then why mention anything about it at all? You were either being obtuse or were just trying to stir up trouble for me. That part of my comment was obviously just a turn of phrase. You are growing ever more suspicious in my mind.
But, I have a few thoughts in regard to
Valier other than what
TGWBS said, although similar to
Amanaduial. I’m actually more interested in some of the things she said in earlier days, these things can stay in the back of a person’s mind to be revived at a later date. If she had pointed a finger at a wolf early and then dropped it, the wolves might think this a good time to get rid of her. Skipping over the irrelevant posts…Valier’s attitude toward Cailín, I agree with Amanaduial, needs consideration. As has been said above she was always suspicious of Cailín (this started in post 150). This continued in post 180 where she mentioned Cailín alongside Garin and Lhuna. Then, suddenly in post 216, Valier said she trusted Cailín a little more and voted for Garin (huzzah). Then in her famous post 244 she says she believes Cailín is innocent. If Cailín is a werewolf, last NIGHT was the perfect time to rub out Valier. That, at least, is what I glean from Valier’s posting and I think it is something to keep in mind.
Regarding the Seer, while I remain hesitant, some of the points Farael made seem compelling to me. I think it is perhaps time for the Seer to step forward and tell what they know, especially if they know the name of a wolf (although I kind of doubt it). In fact, I’m rather afraid that the Seer is not currently in possession of a great deal of ground breaking information. There is a good chance that at least one person the Seer asked about is already dead. However, if we can assemble at least some semblance of a list of innocents, perhaps it will be enough to do us some good and the wolves won’t be able to kill the innocents off quickly enough to save themselves. I’m not so sure I agree about the Hunter…but it probably is time for the Seer. Unfortunately, unless we get a wolf the Seer (and inevitably the Apprentice) may not have a whole lot to work with. There is still a large element of risk with this.
I do have a theory I would like to propose, but I am going to wait until later in the DAY to do so in order to give the Seer a chance to reveal anything they may know.