A Case for Innocence
(Not for me, silly; it would be wasted keystrokes. Better make my death good though,
Formodacil. Maybe something with pitchforks or trees or giant devouring spiders.
)
Sorry, I lost my downloaded copy of the thread (which would have allowed me to analyse everything in the comfort of my home, instead of being harried by monetary considerations in internet cafés), so I couldn't do a proper case against someone. It would take more to convince of guilt than of innocence (for me, at least), so this is the best I could do. Hope it would suffice.
Most of the information here are based on the voting (and the resulting lynching of a Werewolf) that happened yesterDAY (qv. Appendix below).
Lhunardawen
I am almost completely sure of her innocence. Most of my arguments can be seen in post
258. Also, I realised that her vote for me DAY 1 (which made me initially suspicious of her) was simply her seeing what some of you failed to see: Dice don't have memory, and neither do WW role assignments.
Valier
Rune Son of Bjarne
If either of these two were werewolves, they're very bold and smart (or the werewolves concocted an excellent sacrifice plan, although considering what the Seer could do with a dead Werewolf, it's highly unlikely.) They were the ones that gave impetus to the
Garin bandwaggon.
Gurthang
He suggested quite a good plan early in the game, usually a good sign of a thinking, helpful villager. Plus, he was the one that sealed
Garin's fate.
Kuruharan
He's the one I'm least sure of. He also was the vote that killed
Garin, although, being more experienced, it could have been part of a Werewolvish plan. (He said in
222 that he was monitoring the thread while posting, which suggests he knew that he'd cross-post.)
Appendix
DAY 2 votes with voting times (GMT). Possible cross-posts in groups.
05:55 Alcarillo- Cailín (Cailín 1)
08:47 Lhuna - Eluchíl (Cailín 1 - Eluchíl 1)
10:49 Amanaduial - Lhuna (Cailín 1 - Eluchíl 1 - Lhuna 1)
13:13 Nilp - Cailín (Cailín 2 - Eluchíl 1 - Lhuna 1)
19:22 Farael- Garin (Cailín 2 - Eluchíl 1 - Lhuna 1 - Garin 1)
19:50 malkatoj - Lhuna (Cailín 2 - Eluchíl 1 - Lhuna 2 - Garin 1)
20:16 Rune - Garin (Cailín 2 - Eluchíl 1 - Lhuna 2 - Garin 2)
20:30 TGWBS - Lhuna (Cailín 2 - Eluchíl 1 - Lhuna 3 - Garin 2)
21:39 Naria - Cailín (Cailín 3 - Eluchíl 1 - Lhuna 3 - Garin 2)
21:46 Azaelia - Garin (Cailín 3 - Eluchíl 1 - Lhuna 3 - Garin 3)
21:47 Cailín - Eluchíl (Cailín 3 - Eluchíl 2 - Lhuna 3 - Garin 3)
21:50 Valier - Garin (Cailín 3- Eluchíl 2 - Lhuna 3 - Garin 4)
21:58 Kuruharan - Garin (Cailín 3 - Eluchíl 2 - Lhuna 3 - Garin 5)
21:58 Garin - Lhuna (Cailín 3 - Eluchíl 2 - Lhuna 4 - Garin 5)
21:59 Gurthang - Garin (Cailín 3 - Eluchíl 2 - Lhuna 4 - Garin 6)