Well, I'm headed to bed soon, so I will vote now, even with the minimal discussion.
I think Menel is innocent, that malkatoj's and Naria's excuses are reasonable, and I can also see the reason behind voting for Gil-Galad or for Nilp (both are confusing). People seem to be blowing Cailin's post today (after Garin's and before Kuru's) out of proportion, but Kuru does say Cailin was mentioned by Kath. Maybe the former didn't pick up on the latter's cobbler-clue, or thought it was just an odd choice of vocabulary.
Let me go look at Kath's post. I shall return shortly.
|