The Barrow-Downs Discussion Forum - View Single Post - Tol-in-Gaurhoth XV-The Villagers Strike Back!

mormegil · 12-21-2005, 01:17 PM

I have a great plan that might save a bunch of you prats. Now listen to me and listen good! We have 14 total left, 2 of them heroes, 3 gifted and 9 innocents. Now, Draugluin knows who one innocent is being as he/she protected them last night. There is a chance that who was protected was Sauron but it's unknown. Now Sauron has been able to learn the identity of 3 others, hopefully one hero but more than likely only innocents. That means they could know up to 3 innocents but likely at least one is dead, so I will go with 2. And we have Carcharoth hidden among us. That would make 5 to 7 known innocents. More than likely it's 6 but out of 14 that's not too bad. There is a chance that overlap could exist, ie Sauron dreamt of Carcharoth or Draugluin protected somebody that Sauron dreamt of.

What I propose is for all to step forward and let us know what they know. This would narrow the field by almost half. Then they could orchestrate a double devouring (think of all the meat) of the two highest suspects on that list. It's likely that Draugluin would be the first to die then Sauron but Sauron would be able to get one more dream in and we would have another double devouring.

The plan might be best implemented today however it may be best to do tomorrow. Of course I will let those who know best decide. This of course could be seen as a ploy to get the gifteds to reveal themselves but think about it, at this point I don't think a hero would want this, to be more visible in a group of 7 to 8 as opposed to a group of 14.

I still hold that Gurthang is guilty and he is not sitting right with me. I think I will vote for him today if the plan is not implented.

12-21-2005, 01:17 PM	#179
mormegil Maundering Mage Join Date: Apr 2005 Location: Texas Posts: 4,651	I have a great plan that might save a bunch of you prats. Now listen to me and listen good! We have 14 total left, 2 of them heroes, 3 gifted and 9 innocents. Now, Draugluin knows who one innocent is being as he/she protected them last night. There is a chance that who was protected was Sauron but it's unknown. Now Sauron has been able to learn the identity of 3 others, hopefully one hero but more than likely only innocents. That means they could know up to 3 innocents but likely at least one is dead, so I will go with 2. And we have Carcharoth hidden among us. That would make 5 to 7 known innocents. More than likely it's 6 but out of 14 that's not too bad. There is a chance that overlap could exist, ie Sauron dreamt of Carcharoth or Draugluin protected somebody that Sauron dreamt of. What I propose is for all to step forward and let us know what they know. This would narrow the field by almost half. Then they could orchestrate a double devouring (think of all the meat) of the two highest suspects on that list. It's likely that Draugluin would be the first to die then Sauron but Sauron would be able to get one more dream in and we would have another double devouring. The plan might be best implemented today however it may be best to do tomorrow. Of course I will let those who know best decide. This of course could be seen as a ploy to get the gifteds to reveal themselves but think about it, at this point I don't think a hero would want this, to be more visible in a group of 7 to 8 as opposed to a group of 14. I still hold that Gurthang is guilty and he is not sitting right with me. I think I will vote for him today if the plan is not implented. __________________ “I wish it need not have happened in my time," said Frodo. "So do I," said Gandalf, "and so do all who live to see such times. But that is not for them to decide. All we have to decide is what to do with the time that is given us.”