The Barrow-Downs Discussion Forum - View Single Post - Tol-in-Gaurhoth XV-The Villagers Strike Back!

Meneltarmacil · 12-19-2005, 05:02 PM

In analyzing who Hero #1, the one riding the Glirdan bandwagon, is, I find Oddwen to be a possibility. She posts every now and then to show us that she's here, yet offers very little analysis in her posts, intead acting completely crazy and tossing out silly reasons to vote for people. She then joins a rapidly-moving bandwagon, trying to cover it up by saying "Haha, I'm bandwagoning," implying that she's not, in an attempt to throw us off.

A secondary suspect is mormegil due to the fact that he put Glirdan in the lead by casting a second vote. However, since the competition consisted of an Ordinary Wolf (yours truly) and HuanPan Man, whose identity definitely was not known by the Heroes at the time (otherwise they wouldn't have killed him), this doesn't say much.

Farael is yet another possibility, as he has been quite silent and offers little.
As for Wayne, same thing though my theory presumes that he is innocent. However, he may not be

I can probably eliminate morm for reasons stated above. Farael and Wayne are pretty much unknowns. Oddwen, however, could certainly offer more than she has thus far. I will keep a close eye on her from now on, as she has become my primary suspect for Hero#1.

To sum up my findings:
Hero#1: Oddwen
Hero#2: Boromir88, or possibly dancing spawn of ungoliant
Hero#3: Rune son of Bjarne

EDIT: Changed "eaten" to "killed," cross-posted with morm

12-19-2005, 05:02 PM	#125
Meneltarmacil Ghost Prince of Cardolan Join Date: Jun 2003 Location: The bottom of the ocean, discussing philosophy with a giant squid Posts: 2,254	In analyzing who Hero #1, the one riding the Glirdan bandwagon, is, I find Oddwen to be a possibility. She posts every now and then to show us that she's here, yet offers very little analysis in her posts, intead acting completely crazy and tossing out silly reasons to vote for people. She then joins a rapidly-moving bandwagon, trying to cover it up by saying "Haha, I'm bandwagoning," implying that she's not, in an attempt to throw us off. A secondary suspect is mormegil due to the fact that he put Glirdan in the lead by casting a second vote. However, since the competition consisted of an Ordinary Wolf (yours truly) and HuanPan Man, whose identity definitely was not known by the Heroes at the time (otherwise they wouldn't have killed him), this doesn't say much. Farael is yet another possibility, as he has been quite silent and offers little. As for Wayne, same thing though my theory presumes that he is innocent. However, he may not be I can probably eliminate morm for reasons stated above. Farael and Wayne are pretty much unknowns. Oddwen, however, could certainly offer more than she has thus far. I will keep a close eye on her from now on, as she has become my primary suspect for Hero#1. To sum up my findings: Hero#1: Oddwen Hero#2: Boromir88, or possibly dancing spawn of ungoliant Hero#3: Rune son of Bjarne EDIT: Changed "eaten" to "killed," cross-posted with morm __________________ I ♣ baby seals.