[Lathriel]

The only thing that realy bothered me with weathertop was that Strider just left the hobbits for no apparent reason. He's like,"Here are your swords,bye." He doesn't even tell them to keep a fire going since ringwraiths are afraid of it. I think this is a crucial point, so why didn't Strider inform the Hobbits about it?
Even if the ringwraiths didn't make any noise in the book their screams in the movie worked for me. Especially inROTK I found them to be very creepy.
Also as I mentioned in the other thread, I don't like the orc-breeding.
One thing that I dol ike of the Isengard sequence is the moth, especially because the music that accompanies it is gorgeous. I also like the industrialization part because it illustrates one of Tolkien's major concerns and at least PJ and crew drew attention to that aspect.
More later,if I have time.