[HerenIstarion]

Deadnight Chanter
Posts: 1056
Re: Mithladan

I deem he must have been numbered among the eldar, and to be precise, among Noldor. But he reached Aman not, for no noldo was accepted to blessed realm until the time of Morgoth's overthrown and lifting of the ban on their return, so it may be assumed that Tuor and Idril perished in the sea, and got to the halls of awaiting. As for their probable reincarnation (for them, being faithful in a sense, needed not to abode there long) there is no textual evidence of that, nor even hint, as far as I know.