2 argunments not yet here
The actor who played Grishnakh would, I think, have done the ring-driven version of the scese well (in fact, I hear that version done by the movie actors when I read that scene in the book)
And, the book-version requires that Eomer use his un-stupid strategy, rather then rushing in blindly.
but when you watch the film, the film version is entertaining.
__________________
I support...something.
|