well ill jump in here. sorry im a bit late. i was going to post earilier but got interupted. rather rudely, i might add. anyway...
haveing not read all the posts, i am quite intregued. there a few possible senarios that arrise from the wilwa=seer idea. which im not 100% sold on, by the way.
normally, i would say: "wolf? a wolf would never be so foolish to do something like that. innocent? she's not fea, you know. seer? must be." but given teh rather close shave she had with the noose last evening, that on longer holds true. ok three senarios.
wilwa is a wolf:
wilwa as a wolf could do us great damage. first she could be hoping to take down an innocent with her. actually this would accomplish two things. the other being to render our vote useless as a record tomarrow, because all the votes would be assumed to be for wilwa. cuz we would know she is a wolf after lynching a supposed innocnet wayne. the other thing would be flushing out the seer. the only way to prove that she isn't the seer is for teh real seer to come out. (actually, only the hypothetically real seer adn wayne know if she is telling the truth, just realized that.) i think that is a rather sever amount of damage deal for one wolf kill.
wilwa is the seer:
could be. she could have seen how close she got to death yesterday and freaked out (i know all about that
.) she has one know wolf that she would want to get recognized. not only that, she has one dream left (possibley two, though that is playing a dangerous game there ranger!). not a bad haul for a seer.
wilwa is innocent:
umm. you better not be
.
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by wilwa
You want proof?
I dreamt of you last night Firefoot, you are an Ordinary Villager.
Now do you believe me?
|
no. that does nothing to assuage my doubts. you know who everone is if you are a wolf. although now that i think of it it kind of does, a bit, cuz you would be playing a desparate game saying that directly to a fellow wolf.
here's some stuff about wayne:
if wilwa is the seer, wayne must be a wolf. if wilwa is infact a wolf, there are two differnt lines of logic she could choose:
pick a wolf, so when we lynch her, we will trust her. this is doubtful, cuz the idea isn't to have us trust her, its just to have us trust her for a day. the wolf sacrafise would be a long-run option.
pick an innocent to bring down with her. not a bad idea.
so as for what im thinking overall, i don't think we should lynch wayne. that would be kind of counter productive, becasue we have a huge bullseye on his head if wilwa is the seer, and we have a known innocent if she's a wolf.
more next time...
edited mixed some stuff up. sorry.