The Barrow-Downs Discussion Forum - View Single Post - Tol-in-Gaurhoth XIII: Enter Shamville

littlemanpoet · 11-10-2005, 04:12 PM

If Wilwa is not the seer, then the real seer absolutely must step forward and say so. If no-one comes forward to contest Wilwa's claim, then we may consider the matter wrapped up. Wayne is therefore a werewolf, which surprises none of us.

Wilwa, it's important that you name who the innocents were that you dreamed of. Known innocents are an important way for the innocent villagers to keep the werewolves in reaction mode. I note that yesterDay you defended the following: LMP, Firefoot, Anguirel, Kitanna. Please tell us who the innocents are.

Glirdan, your tally is incorrect.

The order of vote:
1. Glirdan : Lalaith (1)
2. Kitanna: Wilwa (1)
3. Firefoot: Menel (1)
4. Lalaith: Wilwa (2)
5. tar ancalime: LMP (1)
6. LMP: Wilwa (3)
7. Celuien: Menel (2)
8. Anguirel: Menel (3)
9. Menel: LMP (2)
10. Eonwe: Menel (4)
11. Kath: Menel (5)
12. Wayne: Wilwa (4)
Wilwa did not vote. Quite a smart thing, considering.

Wayne had cross-posted with Kath, and didn't know that Menel had already been given a 5th vote; quite a cynical thing to try to cause a double-lynching of two people we now know to be innocent; this condemns Wayne doubly.

So I think that in our voting on Day 2, every one of us voted for an innocent. Not good. But now we can rectify that. I'm not sure that yesterDay's voting is going to help us much at all in determing who the werewolves are.

One thing is certain, the Ranger needs to guard Wilwa tonight.

11-10-2005, 04:12 PM	#204
littlemanpoet Itinerant Songster Join Date: Jan 2002 Location: The Edge of Faerie Posts: 7,066	If Wilwa is not the seer, then the real seer absolutely must step forward and say so. If no-one comes forward to contest Wilwa's claim, then we may consider the matter wrapped up. Wayne is therefore a werewolf, which surprises none of us. Wilwa, it's important that you name who the innocents were that you dreamed of. Known innocents are an important way for the innocent villagers to keep the werewolves in reaction mode. I note that yesterDay you defended the following: LMP, Firefoot, Anguirel, Kitanna. Please tell us who the innocents are. Glirdan, your tally is incorrect. The order of vote: 1. Glirdan : Lalaith (1) 2. Kitanna: Wilwa (1) 3. Firefoot: Menel (1) 4. Lalaith: Wilwa (2) 5. tar ancalime: LMP (1) 6. LMP: Wilwa (3) 7. Celuien: Menel (2) 8. Anguirel: Menel (3) 9. Menel: LMP (2) 10. Eonwe: Menel (4) 11. Kath: Menel (5) 12. Wayne: Wilwa (4) Wilwa did not vote. Quite a smart thing, considering. Wayne had cross-posted with Kath, and didn't know that Menel had already been given a 5th vote; quite a cynical thing to try to cause a double-lynching of two people we now know to be innocent; this condemns Wayne doubly. So I think that in our voting on Day 2, every one of us voted for an innocent. Not good. But now we can rectify that. I'm not sure that yesterDay's voting is going to help us much at all in determing who the werewolves are. *One thing is certain, the Ranger needs to guard Wilwa* tonight.** Last edited by littlemanpoet; 11-10-2005 at 05:42 PM.