[Anguirel]

Gothmog, the sons of Feanor in this version were not guilty of most of the crimes you throw at them.

We avoided the Kinslaying at Alqualonde; the Teleri sailed willingly.

The sons of Feanor were present in the assault on Doriath-to drive back Morgoth's army! They saved Dior, fighting alongside him. Later, they wiped out the thieving Dwarves.

The turn of events in evictions have changed a lot. Maedhros and Maglor have behaved honourably and wisely and deserve the gem.

As for the help coming from Valinor-how do you know there'll be any? The Valar are quarreling with each other, and of the Valarin Host that fought the War of Wrath, almost every participant

Eonwe
Ingwe
Finarfin

is dead or evicted. Maedhros may be needed to marshal resistance in the uncertain times ahead.