[Anguirel]

There are two sides to every conflict. If Elwing and her her family can be induced to hand back the Silmaril peaceably, it will not burn Maedhros and war will be stopped without the tragic necessity of evicting the great High King of the Noldor.

Remember Elwing has no feud with the brothers. Indeed, they avenged her family's death by wiping out Telchar's Dwarves. It may be easier to reach a compromise.

Let's look at who is currently influencing Elwing's decision in Sirion.

Ereinion Gil-Galad-an ambitious scion of Fingolfin's house. Stands to gain the High Kingship if Maedhros and Maglor fall. However, a noble and chivalrous character not connected particularly to any desire for the Silmaril.

Salgant-probably jealous of Maglor's harp prowess, but an inveterate coward who would like to avoid war.

Mablung-the last of the Doriath old guard, took part in the hunting of Carcharoth and served the over-mighty Melian. Remembers the Quest of the Silmaril and will resent giving it up.

Cirdan-ancient, wise, peacable, not possessive.

Celebrian-young, but of high and ambitious blood. May resent the Silmaril's surrender, but doesn't have the power to influence Elwing Mablung does.

Earendil-concerned with voyaging and getting help from the West. Does not yet connect this with the Silmaril.

Elrond
Elros-Elwing's children. Remembering her brothers, she will desire to keep them safe, by avoiding war. May be hardened to battle if they die.

So, as an alternative to Maedhros, I suggest Mablung. The voting will close at 7:30 tomorrow morning. I know it's been a long day...I'm a bit snowed under...

++MABLUNG