|
Doesn't Elwing still have the silmarill? If we can evict her maybe the new bearer will give it up willingly to the sons of feanor still alive. I do not see any reason why their claim to it should have been taken away in this Silarillion, it seems that the Sindar have done the most elf-elf violence. With the exceptions of Celegorm and Curufin thr sons of feanor haven't attacked their fellow elves, so maybe if we evict Elwing they will give MAedhros the silmarill
++Elwing
|