Much of what I was planning on saying seems to have been said already. So I'm going to try not to repeat what others have already stated because no one wants to read a post like that.
I've stated Glirdan, Bergil, and Wayne as suspects, but I am not sure I want to vote for them. Glirdan has me confused, but at this point I am inclined to move him quite low on my suspect list. Bergil and Wayne both have rather baseless and random votes, but seeing as it is day one and my own vote (and I'm sure other people's votes) are random.
lmp seems to be the one trying to generate the most conversation. I like that. He is proposing ideas and defends them and it is causing people to say more. Which is very good. I think he is worth keeping around for a while.
Firefoot, Kath, and Menel all disagreed with lmp's plan and I can see where they are coming from. Of course it has a terrible downside, but most of the plans used in WW do. Kath and Firefoot both make very helpful posts. Menel does too, but I find Firefoot and Kath's more helpful than his. But all three should be kept around past DAY 1.
Kuru also had a proposed idea of silence and then everyone simply votes. Now that is an easy way for a wolf too hide, but also a rather foolish thing for a wolf to do. Wolves like to take a bandwagon approach and if everyone is silent there is no way to bandwagon without calling attention to oneself. At the moment I'd say half of me thinks Kuru is a wolf and the other half doesn't. I'll watch him closely in the days to come.
So that leaves me with Anguirel, Lalaith, tar-ancalime, Wilwarin538, Eonwe, and Celuien to vote for.
Anguriel seems to be leaning toward Wayne because of Wayne's lack of substance. Somewhat random, but at the same time reasonable. It is easy to get rid of posters like Wayne because they often confuse the village. So I see where he is coming from. Of course that doesn't mean I'd put in that vote today.
Lalaith disagreed with lmp's plan, but sees how it can benefit us as a village. She wants us to talk more. Which of course is an easy place for a wolf to hide in.
Tar said little to start with and then disagreed with lmp's plan. Asks for more substance from Anguriel. Also states "something feels wring in his posts." Interesting... Also calls to hear more from Wilwa and Lalaith.
Wilwa has really said nothing of much help. Thinks Bergil gives a stupid reason for voting for her and questions Wayne's vote.
Eonwe as usual calls for explanations of people's suspects and votes. Quite reasonable really. Can't really understand Glirdan's vote for him.
Celuin has been the least helpful for me personally. Her second post was slightly helpful in summarizing what had been said so far and she said no one was suspicious in her eyes. She maintained that standpoint again in her third post. Then she mentions Glirdan and Bergil and says she will keep an eye on them. Then she says (under Glirdan and Bergil) that tar and Wayne bear watching. It was nothing truly helpful to go off of.
++ CELUIEN
This vote isn't entirely random, but it is not very concrete either. I tried to find neon signs that pointed out the wolves, but it is just not happening. Hopefully tomorrow will be more helpful in rooting out the wolves.
EDIT: Votes stand as such:
Wilwa = 1 vote from Bergil
Eonwe = 1 vote from Glirdan
Bergil = 1 vote from Wayne
Lalaith = 1 vote from Firefoot
Anguriel = 1 vote from tar
Tar = 1 vote from lmp
Wayne = 2 votes from Anguriel and Celuin
Celuien = 1 vote from me
__________________
"Let us live so that when we come to die even the undertaker will be sorry." - Mark Twain
Last edited by Kitanna; 11-07-2005 at 12:06 PM.
|