[Gothmog]

You beastly anti-Celegormists, leave me my last C. I killed one voluntarily for you, yet you vote them away before their time...fie on ye...

May I be one of those?
I did read the story and it was beautiful, well written and all. But no pity for Celegorm, no. As before, I feel pity for those of the brothers which could have been great, noble leaders ef elves and because of the oath and their brothers was dragged into a net of murders and grief. Like Maglor. And Maedhros. They both showed "human" sides from time to time, especially Maglor. And that is seen in the story too, but Celegorm shows no signs of regret or feelings of guilt over what they've done. He and Curufin was lost from the first words of the oath I'm afraid.

And yes, i was both surprised and happy to see Caranthir go, but i will not give up before all off the Cs is gone. Maglor and Maedhros deserves a second chance in life, and it'll be interesting to see their development without the influence of their brothers.

And no over to the voting...This result could create a love-triangle of great proportions. A man, an elf and a dwarf? Wow... Not even in a tragic work like Silmarillion did something like thet occur. It will lead to disaster, and therefor I hope The 1,000th Reader will vote again with something of a reason to back up his voting. His choice's were good though

P.S. tack så mycket, Rune. Din hjälp är alltid välkommen. Antar att jag blir skyldig dig en gentjänst om vi får ut Celegorm.