Boy, I wish that I could have participated in that one. Alas, attendance at a work seminar prevented me (although, as it turned out, I did have internet access there). Still, for a game that I wasn't playing in, I did seem to feature rather a lot ...
Whether I am playing, or merely standing on the sidelines cheering, I always seem to become convinced that someone innocent is a Wolf. For the last two Days, I was shouting at my screen for you all to lynch
Esty.
I couldn't understand why everyone seemed so confident in her innocence.
Mind you, I was also shouting at you all for lynching
Boro, who was quite clearly innocent to me. So at least I got something right.
Great game and well played by all concerned. But particular praise for
Boro (whose "new persona" amused me greatly),
lmp (for his early lecherous antics),
morm (for being so clearly committed to the cause) and
Esty and
Underhillo (for getting into the swing of things remarkably quickly, given the experience of many of the other players). Bad luck to the Wolves too, who made the best of a bad situation. A difficult set of innocents to deceive, and it looks from
phantom's list that
Eomer's pick to hunt
Cailin was at least part random, given that he chose her on Night 1. Although credit must go to
Eomer for the move which set up the conditions for a villager win and for, I believe, the first successful use of the Hunter's specific gift.
I would praise
the phantom too for his outstanding moderation (both in formulating the rules and for the narraction), but I am afraid that, if I did, his head would swell to such proportions that it would burst out of my screen ...
