[Feanor of the Peredhil]

Originally Posted by Estelyn Telcontar

What if Boromir is the remaining wolf, who deliberately voted for Formy, a known wolf, all along to get us to trust him?

*cough* Then I'd have been right all along with my Boromir bashing? I'd only just begun to think that he was the Seer based on his insistence at Weremendacil. But then again, I was a little worried about his talk about never assuming the innocence of anybody, and yet saying that he pretty much trusted the Innocent Three. Way to be a hypocrite, no?

Originally Posted by Firefoot

Mr. Underhill - I'm not too concerned about him. His posts seem to have been written in good faith, and some of his comments, though brief, have been very shrewd. I'm not going to discount him, but I think there are several people who are far more suspicious than he is right now.

Originally Posted by morm

This was her last post about Mister Underhill it would seem to say that he's innocent and that she dreamt of him.

Quite the contrary, she says "I'm not going to discount him" which makes me think she didn't dream of him.

Originally Posted by mormy

Edit: cross post with Fea....Why did you forget Encai? Also I think Underhill is cleared by what I've said. It's nice to know that we can't have 2 wolves working together now though.

Because it was almost 2:00 AM? Okay, Encai: Day One: votes innocent (Ang), suspects guilty (Cailin), gives decent strategy. Day Two: votes innocent (Shelob) which saves me, suspects innocent plus two unknowns. Day Three: votes Boromir, who may or may not be a really ballsy wolf. The biggest thing to bother me about Encai is that she saved me. I have no idea why she did it. I won't deny being relieved about it, because who actually wants to die in these villages? When you die, your spirit watches helpless as the village stumbles around, and the worst thing is, usually the second you die, you know who at least one wolf is.

Here's Firefoot's say on the matter: she didn't dream of Encai. "I haven't seen anything to strongly suggest her guilt" which means she hadn't dreamt yet and "I'd like to have a close look at her tomorrow" which I take to mean she planned on it.

Originally Posted by Firefoot

What's to be said? She makes me nervous, but I do feel like she was set up. I'm not so sure that there isn't something in the Fea/Encai theory

This changed my mind. I don't think she dreamt of me, or she'd have said "As I'm seeing evidence that Fea might have been set up, I think this theory is a bit far-fetched" or something like that. I love how she uses the word see. I didn't notice it until I started looking for it. Could somebody be a dove and find all of her uses of it while I'm away at my [wenching] classes? I won't be back until mid-afternoon, like I mentioned before I went to bed. I'm surprised I woke up early enough to post this, to be honeset.

EDIT: cross-post with Boromir.

Especially early in the game when Formendacil was not attracting much suspicion at all, just from me? If you think so, then you people are just crazy.

Surely everyone's heard by now that I'm "Bonkers as Conkers"? Crazy works. Especially after logic fails.