[Firefoot]

Hm, maybe I am being general, aren't I? Probably because I was trying to respond to seven hours' posting in one post. So here's something hopefully a little more comprehensive:

Anguirel - Starts out with some generalities about the wolves and their probable behaviors. He warns about making generalizations and leaves instructions for the Seer not to reveal his/herself. He wants us to work together. (43) He does some commenting on other people's posting so far, though he doesn't really draw many conclusions as he sets out to do, instead just stating the facts. (50) He defends himself a bit, then issues another warning to the Seer. He also volunteers himself for the noose. (54, 58, 60) He votes Boromir as a random pick from the men. (66, 90) Also, a couple of insubstantial posts not worth commenting on. Anguirel does a lot of commenting on the action, (and what he says tends to make sense, though that isn't necessarily an indicator of innocence) though he seems to have very few personal comments on the people. This is mildly suspicious to me.

Boromir - Points out some people for suspicion, including a mystical person not known in this village - this is interesting, I'm not sure if it might mean anything; a wolf might have already looked closer at the list of villagers than that - likely to generate discussion. (48) He makes some good comments; he expresses his doubt that Ang is guilty despite his vote of him - he's pretty firm on the topic of Esty's guilt - jokingly, I'd think. (69, 70) Recants doubts of Esty, states that he thinks wolvish triumvirite is Fea, lmp, and Formen. (105) He seems to be innocent to me, blundering around in the dark.

Cailin - Generalities. (42) Expresses support of Ang's statements. (45) Expresses desire not to vote for Lhuna or Shelob, also feels doubtful of myself and Esty. (102) There's not much to go on for her. She's not said a whole lot; I'm feeling neutral.

Encai - talks about voting system strategies; doesn't want one volunteer to be lynched. Thinks Ang is either innocent or bluffing wolf. (75) I agree with what she said, but there's not enough to go on to make any judgments. I'd like to hear more.

Eomer - Standard opening comments. (47) Thinks he's spotted something of importance, is unspecific. (52) Agrees that seer should stay hidden. (59) Says that whomever he votes for will have irritated him. (79) I'd like to know what he was talking about in 52, but that's his judgment. He's not posted anything really substantial yet, but what he has said is making sense. I'm leaning toward his innocence. After writing this: Votes Boromir, comments that he's scrambling for reasons (107).

Esty - Opening comments. (44) Defends herself against Boromir's accusations. (51) Expresses doubt on who to vote for (81, 93, 96) Votes Shelob based on lack of posting. (97) Obviously she has some doubts not having been in an infected village, and that could be all it is, which is how I am inclined to think. I'd like to hear some more, though obviously that won't happen until tomorrow. I'm not overly suspicious of her.

Fea - She gives some tongue-in-cheek strategy. (74) Comments vaguely, explains vagueness briefly. (92, 95) This could either be Fea being herself or Fea making us think she's being too absurd to be a wolf. I'm equally willing to believe either at this point. She's certainly on my watchlist, but then... she's Fea.

Formendacil - Disagrees with a wholly random lynching, suggests an everyone-abstain system. (61) Disputes Morm's plan. (64) More of the same. (73) Is suspicious of Morm and Ang; says lmp would be a good candidate for random vote. (103) Somehow seems much more vocal than he is, so I'd say that means he's been contributing well. I'm not sure about him; he seems innocent but I'm uncomfortable with some of the things he says. He's definitely on my watchlist.

Lhuna - Unknown.

Lmp - In-character (as bartender) comments, not much pertinence on discussion. (53, 55, 78) Defends himself briefly to me. (57) Discourages Ang from volunteering to vote, advises loudmouthiness to disguise Seer. (77) Expresses disagreement with Morm's plan. (80) Record of support, accusations, etc., unaccompanied by comments. (82) He's somewhat suspicious; he could be a wolf hiding behind his frequent posts and bartenderness. I'm not sure about him. After: official suspect list of Boromir, Fea, and Mr. Underhill. (108)

Mr. Underhill - Doesn't quite understand Morm's plan, asks for clarification. (72) I really can't tell much about him, he's just about as unknown as Lhuna and Shelob. I would like to hear more from him.

Mormegil - Opening comments, doubt on Eomer - to produce discussion, likely. (41) Suggests everyone vote for a random person off the list (49). Thinks he understands Eomer's cryptic post. (56) Supports his plan. (62) Finds Ang's vote odd in that it's not as random as Ang seems to be proposing. (71) Realizes his plan may not be the best, but is glad it generated discussion. (76, 87) Doesn't want to vote off a quiet one. (100) Is suspicious of Cailin, Esty, and TGWBS. (104) Overall he seems innocent to me. He seems to be following his regular plan of generate discussion and evaluate it. His random plan isn't one I'd agree with, but that's the only thing.

Shelob - Unknown

TGWBS - Declares he's not a weredwarf. (67) Dislikes how some haven't spoken, votes for Shelob for that reason (various posts between 80 and 100).

That took long enough! And yes, I did start getting lazy towards the end (i.e., TGWBS, Morm, and LMP, I didn't spend as much time on yours...) But I guess my current list of suspicions is: Fea, Formendacil, and LMP, though I'm entirely open for persuasion.