I would never dream of criticizing you Anguirel, but I sense a tiny bit of biased writing
Anyway: we managed to stop the slaying. That's very good, even if we payed a high prize if you listen to me. We've lost a strong character, the only one who could challenge Morgoth in powers. Well, so be it...
Next task: Inheritance. There's a lot of elves who might think themselves worthy of the title High King of Noldor. There'll be a discussion about who's the most noble to go first and then there'll be the question of wether or not the title should be inherited at all, and if so only father-son or also father-daugther.
I'd say among all elves in ME, Olwe would be the highest. But this title concerns the Noldor alone. So: Finwe was King of all Noldor in the west and Feanor is his eldest son. Feanor could be a strong ruler, but what worries me is some of his sons. But Maedhros is the oldest and he might turn out real fine.
But that oath of Feanor... If he got the power, I fear he would do anything to get his beloved jewels back and that might cause unnecessary suffering.
Fingolfin is a strong and and valiant and Finarfin the wisest. A combination of the three would be the optimum.
I haven't decide who to vote for yet but (and this is hard for me to admit) right now, Feanor is the rightful King.