I think it would be churlish not to automatically select my active MM players.
All of them coped very sportingly with the twists of fate (and yours truly's wagnerian/ Basil Fawlty thrashing a Hillman Imp with a tree type moments and arbitrary decisions). Ideally I would co-opt Oddwen as a co-moderator.... (in the same way I would ideally play doubles with Roger Federer....) She was inspired.....
Kitanna was a wonderful seer in that she had two strikes. Unfortunately a superb trio (later quartet) of wolves managed to raise suspicion against her and she was lost.
Mormegil was incredibly charismatic ( I still haven't recovered from Night 2's PMs reading Mormegil. Mormegil. Mormegil.... Even when the seer had been revealed he nearly talked himself from the gallows. Superb entertainment for a mod. Fea rose to the occasion and played a blinder. And noone does quite and creepy quite like Oromin.
Holby I would transfer to Hunter... for her perception though TGWBS had the right ideas - just unfortunately not quite at the right time.... he kept admirably in character too.
Kath did sterling work as Mythomaniac deliberately picking a wolf!!! Ah well.. almost makes me want to volunteer to have another go... maybe when I am settled into a new assignment (hopefully another one where colleagues won't be fazed by requests for a gruesome way to kill Inspector Clouseau....)
I would increase the game size a little to allow fresh blood (!)and I think I would especially like to include the Phantom and Kuruharan.... memories of the first game

....
If I managed to recruit sufficient Lab Rats to justify increasing the bloodshed... then Boromir would be Were-Rabbit.. that would be interesting...
And I would like to see The BW play again.... and Laitaine - who did so well having been rather handicapped (ahem) by a certain fellow lycanthrope