The Barrow-Downs Discussion Forum - View Single Post - Welcome to Tol-in-Gauroth XI 'Fall of the Fall'

**The Saucepan Man** · 10-06-2005, 05:50 PM

Phew! All a bit of a scramble at the end there! I wish that I had returned earlier. And I wish in a way that we had lynched wilwarin because, either way, I think that it would have helped us in identifying the remaining Wolf or Wolves. Now the Wolves get to see my reasoning and have the opportunity to adjust their plans accordingly.

I think it quite likely that I shall die to-Night, being probably the most innocent looking one around here and (I hope) a pain in the Wolves’ furry necks. So I shall set out my thoughts on all the remaining villagers now, while I still can.

Boromir88: Early vote for mormegil, before we had much of a chance for discussion got me concerned about him again to-Day (having all but discounted him earlier). He still gets credit for having spotted the Seer’s message (although it remains uncertain whether he did so or not before the Cursed was taken) and for helping to nail Eomer-Wolf. If wilwarin is guilty, he could be the final Wolf. Do not discount him. He’s a shrewd one and would be more than capable of winning the game as a lone Wolf.

Wilwarin: I still strongly suspect her, for the reasons that I have given and that have been given by others. I suggest that, subject to any unexpected developments, she is lynched to-Morrow. The reasoning that I outlined above, with regard to Formendacil and arcticstorm will apply. If she’s innocent, one is most likely a Wolf, and quite possibly both. If not, they can probably (although not definitively) be trusted.

Formendacil: His fate now seems to me to be tied to that of wilwarin - see above. If he is a Wolf, Eomer’s responses to his early vote on Day 1 take on a fresh angle.

Mormegil: We will soon find out. I am grateful to you for having declared me cleared of all suspicion, but I am fearful that it may be a final message to your Wolf buddies advising them to take me out to-Night. If, on the other hand, you are the Hunter, I salute you for you will not have died in vain.

Abercrombie: If morm’s a Wolf, she’s the Hunter. If morm’s the Hunter, she dies.

Arctistorm: Same applies as with regard to Formendacil, although Formen was the most zealous of wilwa’s prosecutors to-Day.

Marcolie: I had thought her a possible Wolf at the outset of to-Day. Her contributions to-Day have lessened my suspicions of her, but she cannot be discounted completely.

Azaelia: I still believe that Cailin’s comments yester-Day indicate that she most probably dreamed of Azaelia and found her to be innocent. It’s still unclear to me whether that would have been before the transformation of the Cursed that Night. Unlikely to be a Wolf, but cannot be discounted completely either, since I may have read Cailin’s comments wrongly (or she may have transformed subsequent to Cailin dreaming about her).

Alcarillo: Who knows? I only wish that he would contribute more.

SpM: Probably Wolf-food tonight. They may leave me alone if they want to try to set me up to-Morrow, but there are more suspicious people round here than me right now, so probably not.

Cheerio!

PS (edit): If either or both of mormegil and wilwarin are Wolves, it would speak in Alcarillo's favour as they targetted him yester-Day as the alternative lynchee to Eomer.

10-06-2005, 05:50 PM	#295
The Saucepan Man Corpus Cacophonous Join Date: Jan 2003 Location: A green and pleasant land Posts: 8,390	Phew! All a bit of a scramble at the end there! I wish that I had returned earlier. And I wish in a way that we had lynched wilwarin because, either way, I think that it would have helped us in identifying the remaining Wolf or Wolves. Now the Wolves get to see my reasoning and have the opportunity to adjust their plans accordingly. I think it quite likely that I shall die to-Night, being probably the most innocent looking one around here and (I hope) a pain in the Wolves’ furry necks. So I shall set out my thoughts on all the remaining villagers now, while I still can. Boromir88: Early vote for mormegil, before we had much of a chance for discussion got me concerned about him again to-Day (having all but discounted him earlier). He still gets credit for having spotted the Seer’s message (although it remains uncertain whether he did so or not before the Cursed was taken) and for helping to nail Eomer-Wolf. If wilwarin is guilty, he could be the final Wolf. Do not discount him. He’s a shrewd one and would be more than capable of winning the game as a lone Wolf. Wilwarin: I still strongly suspect her, for the reasons that I have given and that have been given by others. I suggest that, subject to any unexpected developments, she is lynched to-Morrow. The reasoning that I outlined above, with regard to Formendacil and arcticstorm will apply. If she’s innocent, one is most likely a Wolf, and quite possibly both. If not, they can probably (although not definitively) be trusted. Formendacil: His fate now seems to me to be tied to that of wilwarin - see above. If he is a Wolf, Eomer’s responses to his early vote on Day 1 take on a fresh angle. Mormegil: We will soon find out. I am grateful to you for having declared me cleared of all suspicion, but I am fearful that it may be a final message to your Wolf buddies advising them to take me out to-Night. If, on the other hand, you are the Hunter, I salute you for you will not have died in vain. Abercrombie: If morm’s a Wolf, she’s the Hunter. If morm’s the Hunter, she dies. Arctistorm: Same applies as with regard to Formendacil, although Formen was the most zealous of wilwa’s prosecutors to-Day. Marcolie: I had thought her a possible Wolf at the outset of to-Day. Her contributions to-Day have lessened my suspicions of her, but she cannot be discounted completely. Azaelia: I still believe that Cailin’s comments yester-Day indicate that she most probably dreamed of Azaelia and found her to be innocent. It’s still unclear to me whether that would have been before the transformation of the Cursed that Night. Unlikely to be a Wolf, but cannot be discounted completely either, since I may have read Cailin’s comments wrongly (or she may have transformed subsequent to Cailin dreaming about her). Alcarillo: Who knows? I only wish that he would contribute more. SpM: Probably Wolf-food tonight. They may leave me alone if they want to try to set me up to-Morrow, but there are more suspicious people round here than me right now, so probably not. Cheerio! PS (edit): If either or both of mormegil and wilwarin are Wolves, it would speak in Alcarillo's favour as they targetted him yester-Day as the alternative lynchee to Eomer. __________________ Do you mind? I'm busy doing the fishstick. It's a very delicate state of mind! Last edited by The Saucepan Man; 10-06-2005 at 05:57 PM.